Holiday Unity Fractures As Activists Debate True Victim Of Thanksgiving
WASHINGTON, D.C.—In what was expected to be a unified front against the annual American tradition of Thanksgiving, the progressive coalition to end the holiday has reportedly collapsed into bitter infighting, sources confirmed Tuesday. The schism occurred after PETA’s demand to cancel the presidential turkey pardon was met with accusations from other activists that their cause “perpetuates avian privilege” and “erases the lived experience of historically oppressed root vegetables.”
The conflict began, as it does every November, with PETA issuing its yearly plea for the White House to forgo the pardoning of two turkeys, named this year Liberty and Bell. “The pardon is a performative charade that sanitizes the mass slaughter of 46 million of their brethren,” said fictional PETA spokesperson Juniper Sagebrush, holding a photo of a turkey with a single tear rolling down its feathered cheek. “These two individuals should not be used as props in a ceremony that normalizes a holiday of death. They should be sent to a sanctuary, not exploited for a photo-op.”
However, this traditionally unopposed position within the anti-Thanksgiving movement was immediately challenged by the ‘Thanks-taking Action Collective,’ a group dedicated to dismantling the holiday for its colonialist origins.
“Oh, here we go again. Centering the turkeys,” said Kaelynn-X, a spokesperson for the collective who uses the letter ‘X’ to reject patriarchal naming conventions. “PETA’s obsession with these two privileged birds is a classic example of species-splaining. The presidential pardon is, at its core, a reenactment of a colonial power structure. To demand the turkeys be ‘freed’ is to ignore that their very existence as domesticated poultry is a product of the imperialist-agribusiness complex. They are symbols of the problem, not its victims.”
A Clash of Oppressions
The disagreement quickly escalated on social media, with PETA supporters accusing the Thanks-taking collective of “whataboutism” and a lack of compassion for sentient beings. In response, the collective accused PETA of “fowl play” and promoting a “carnist-adjacent narrative” that prioritizes animal comfort over systemic decolonization.
“Frankly, we find the entire concept of a ‘pardon’ to be problematic,” Kaelynn-X elaborated in a 47-part thread. “It implies the turkeys were guilty of something in the first place, a clear microaggression. Furthermore, focusing on the turkeys completely ignores the silent suffering of the yams, the cranberries, and the exploited pumpkins whose labor makes the entire genocidal feast possible. Where is their pardon?”
The debate has reportedly paralyzed the movement, forcing local chapters to choose sides. A planned joint protest outside the White House has been split into two separate, competing events.
- PETA’s Rally: Scheduled for 10:00 AM on the north side of the White House, with activists dressed as turkeys demanding clemency.
- The Thanks-taking Collective’s Counter-Protest: Scheduled for 10:05 AM, also on the north side, where activists will protest PETA’s protest for being “a distraction from the core issues of settler-colonialism and gourd appropriation.”
White House Responds with Confusion
When asked for comment, a bewildered White House aide said the administration was proceeding with the ceremony as planned. “We receive a number of letters about the pardon every year,” the aide stated, shuffling papers. “But this is the first time we’ve received a petition demanding we not pardon the turkeys but instead put them on trial for historical complicity. We’re… looking into the legal precedent for that.”
As the date of the pardon approaches, the rift shows no signs of healing. PETA has doubled down, releasing a new ad campaign featuring a sad turkey watching its family get stuffed. Meanwhile, the Thanks-taking Action Collective has announced plans to hold a “Day of Mourning” for the unrecognized victims of the holiday, including “the sovereignty of the wild onion” and “the dignity of the green bean casserole.”
“At the end of the day, it’s about intersectionality,” concluded Kaelynn-X. “And PETA just doesn’t seem to understand that a turkey’s right to life doesn’t supersede a potato’s right to not be mashed without its consent.”



